The book Sometimes I Scare Myself by Jeneva Rose is a collection of three separate horror stories, each with its own main character and struggle. Here’s a rundown of who they are and what they’re wrestling with:
Main Characters and Their Struggles
-
Erica Hine – In the story Never Kill the Medium. Erica is turning thirty and meticulously plans a birthday dinner to feel safe and in control. Her struggle is with grief and guilt over her sister Joslyn’s death, which she tries to suppress through rigid planning and routine. The evening spirals out of control when a séance reveals buried secrets, forcing Erica to confront her past and admit that control is an illusion. The horror for her comes from losing trust—not just in others but in her own sense of reality.
-
Kristin – In The Nightmare House. A new mother grappling with postpartum fragility, Kristin moves with her husband and children to a house in a quiet town. She faces isolation (both real and perceived), eerie supernatural disturbances, and growing disbelief from those around her. Her struggle is balancing maternal responsibility, her own sanity, and an encroaching sense that something is deeply wrong—something she can’t explain but feels she must stop. The stakes are her family’s lives and her own grip on sanity.
-
Blair – In All Curses Are Final. Recently broken up with her boyfriend Jake, Blair joins her friends for a winter trip to a remote cabin. A cursed object (a hockey-stick pen) sets off a sequence of paranoid survival and betrayal. Blair’s struggle is with her loss of trust—not just in her ex, but in the people she thought were her friends, and in her own judgment. What starts as a personal emotional baggage trip becomes a nightmare where betrayal could kill. Blair must fight both external forces and internal fears to survive.
Overarching Themes
- Control vs. chaos: Each protagonist tries to keep control—over memories, experiences, relationships—but supernatural horror strips that away. - Guilt and grief: Particularly for Erica, but echoed in others, the past weighs heavily and influences how they perceive the threat now. - Isolation and disbelief: Whether it’s being dismissed as overreacting (Kristin), being the guest who notices everything wrong (Erica), or being abandoned by trust (Blair), each character confronts being alone.
Each story features a different main character, but all are connected by their struggle to face fear—in themselves, in others, and in things unseen. If you want a summary or analysis of any particular story or character in more depth, I can go into that next.
Sources
Web search
Open source